We finally decided it was time to take away Luke's soother. To be honest, I think I was more attached to it than he was. But at 2 1/2, it was time for him to do a little growing up. After much discussion, Brandon and I decided the best approach would be to cut it and let Luke find it on his own. This was a good plan for 2 reasons. One, it wouldn't be us against him and he wouldn't feel like we were taking it from him. Two, at 4 in the morning, I couldn't cave in and give it to him so we could all go back to sleep.

So, I snipped the end and left it sitting on the kitchen table for Luke to find on his own. Sure enough, about five minutes after I did it, we hear this from the kitchen, "Oh my soo... OH NO! It's broken!" After about 10 minutes of Daddy trying to fix it several different kinds of tape, he finally accepted the fact that it was broken and with a pouty lip and tears in his eyes, dropped it into the garbage.
Since then we've had some late nights and early mornings, but he's starting to adjust and learn to fall asleep on his own. It's a tough thing having to grow up. Now on to potty training....